Menu of Mooey's Ice Cream in Middlebury, Indiana, USA

Menu Overview

Mooey's Ice Cream, tucked away at 14408 Co Rd 20 in Middlebury, Indiana, is a charming haven for ice cream lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike. This artisanal ice cream shop impresses with its walk-up window service and meticulously maintained outdoor seating, making it a perfect pit stop for travelers on the nearby Pumpkinvine Trail. Despite its modest setup—no indoor dining and only one porta potty—the warmth of the staff and the quality of the offerings more than make up for it.

The menu at Mooey's Ice Cream is a celebration of classic and creative flavors. The Banana Split is a nostalgic delight, layered with fresh bananas, rich ice cream, and luscious toppings that evoke a comforting sense of simple pleasure. The Farmer's Delight stands out with its wholesome, rustic appeal, reflecting the farm-to-table spirit that resonates throughout the region.

For chocolate enthusiasts, the Chocolate Soft Serve paired with thick Hot Fudge delivers deep, velvety richness that lingers long after the last bite. The Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough is another must-try, where creamy ice cream meets the irresistible texture of chewy dough bits, creating a balance between smooth and crunchy. Meanwhile, the Cotton Candy Ice Cream in a Waffle Cup adds a playful twist with its whimsical sweetness and satisfying crunch.

Bold flavor seekers will appreciate the Espresso Chocolate, a perfect pick-me-up where the robust bitterness of espresso harmonizes with velvety chocolate. The Brownie Sundae is decadence personified, marrying fudgy brownie chunks with creamy ice cream and rich sauce. For those who enjoy a savory treat alongside their sweetness, the inclusion of a Soft Pretzel on the menu is a clever touch—offering a salty counterpoint that enhances the overall tasting experience.

What truly distinguishes Mooey's Ice Cream is not just the menu, but the community feel imbued in each visit. Customer reviews reflect a consistent appreciation for the friendly, attentive service and the genuine kindness of the staff. From a helpful team that goes above and beyond—such as holding onto lost items—to the little farm dog greeting visitors, the ambiance is warm and inviting. The location’s rustic charm, coupled with its dedication to crafting phenomenal ice cream, creates a memorable stop whether you’re biking, hiking, or simply craving a sweet treat.

In conclusion, Mooey's Ice Cream is more than just a shop—it is a delightful experience where quality, flavor, and community intersect. Their thoughtfully curated menu highlights both traditional favorites and innovative creations that satisfy every ice cream lover’s palate. If you find yourself in Middlebury or cycling down the Pumpkinvine Trail, do yourself a favor and indulge in Mooey’s exceptional offerings—you’ll leave with a smile and a promise to return.